State-of-the-Art Summary


It is generally accepted that sucker rods operating in normal conditions do not go into compression on the downstroke and only go into compression when excessive fluid pump friction occurs or well condition problems cause opposing forces. Pump friction, which is often misunderstood, comes about from friction between the plunger and barrel interface and can be adjusted by the plunger and barrel fit. A too close clearance will create excessive friction. Another source is the friction of the fluid passing through the traveling valve and the plunger on the downstroke. It is more common with heavier oil and can be remedied by changing the pump design. Rod deflection is mostly due to tight clearances, high linear speed, fluid pound, gas pound, (Figure 3) wellbore deviations and particulates trapped between the plunger and barrel. The larger the plunger, the more likely bucking can occur, especially in deviated wells, so using the smaller diameter plunger and longer stroke length is usually recommended. To counteract this force, sinker bars can be added until the sucker rods are in tension again.

Gas lock occurs when the pump has pumped down to the pump-chamber decompressing limit and the pressure drop inside the pump chamber at the top of the stroke is less than the pump intake pressure. Proper pump design can help to give the pump the highest pump compression and decompression ratio by eliminating uncompressible space in the pump chamber. Adjusting the pumping unit to have a longer stroke will allow the pump to lower the fluid level because the pump decompression limit will increase. Adjusting the rod string to minimize downhole stroke loss is also recommended.

Reducing Electricity Costs

The cost of electricity is a significant part of lifting fluids and producing oil and gas. Rod pumps, compressors, submerged electrical pumps and various surface pumps all consume power. There are two ways to reduce the cost of electricity: use less or pay less. Ron Turner with Oxy described seven specific areas that, with the assistance of a detailed electrical model, could be analyzed for potential reductions in use and improvement in reliability (which in turn reduces downtime and maintenance costs). They are:

  • Install digital relays and recloser controls to record and identify electrical faults and to quickly recover from faults and outages.

  • Reclosers, fuses, and relays must be properly coordinated so that a problem in one area does not cause tripping in another.

  • Install capacitors in conjunction with oilfield motors to reduce the inherent reactive current created by the motors, which does no work but the power company bills for it.

  • Evaluate the need for voltage regulation, particularly at the end of the service line to protect equipment from load fluctuations and poor power quality.

  • Evaluate and install effective grounding protection from lightning.

  • Perform a cost-benefit analysis to determine the value in replacing inefficient motor, transformers and other power-consuming devices with more efficient models.

  • Evaluate the potential savings of operating more efficiently by utilizing adjustable speed drives for those devices that have varying speeds and power demands.

The other side of the cost is the price paid for electricity. While several states have deregulated power (including Texas, Pennsylvania, and Ohio), even those that have not usually have options. Generally, the highest price is to buy firm retail service from the local utility. It usually has a demand component proportional to the highest usage day for the utility to have firm generating capacity reserved for the customer, plus the costs of the electricity itself based on the load characteristics of the operator. The operator must become familiar with the local tariffs to determine the optimum rate for the service required. At minimum there would be an interruptible rate that would have less demand charge. The tariff would define the conditions under which they would interrupt and the utility could tell the historic frequency. Another option could be to aggregate meters to make a more stable, hence less expensive, load pattern. Frequently there are other options between firm and infinitely interruptible.

Toni Holliman (Pioneer) presented the wider array of options available in a deregulated market, where the operator can choose from other suppliers and use the local utility to deliver it. A sample of those, in addition to the utility-provided power include (1) a fixed-price option, where the buyer locks in future prices, (2) pricing in blocks (on-peak, off-peak, around-the-clock), (3) heat-rate option in which the price varies with the cost of fuel, (4) spot pricing, with an option to convert to any of the first three, (5) load acting as a resource, where the buyer has the option to self interrupt and get paid a market-based price for avoided usage, and (6) several variations of an interruptible rate. Considerable savings can be achieved if operators have flexibility on their load.

Figure 3 - Typical Pumping Problems, courtesy Harbison-Fischer


Network News
10


PTTC

3rd Quarter 2006