|
Increasing Oil Recovery Factor
Current recovery factor in mature domestic oil reservoirs
varies considerably depending on geographic region and
reservoir specifics—it might be 30% average recovery in
California and half that in many Midcontinent reservoirs.
In both cases though, there is the potential to
significantly increase the recovery factor being
experienced. Two recent PTTC workshops, in Kansas and
California, focused on doing just that. Addressing typical
local operators in southeast Kansas, PTTC staff
focused on the basics of identifying damage, quantifying
additional potential, and practical approaches a smaller
operator could implement.

Redeveloping State Lease PRC 186, Belmont Field
(click
map to see larger jpeg)
California's reservoirs and the increased technical
capability of companies operating them allows more complex
approaches. PTTC's West Coast Director Iraj Ershaghi noted
two basic approaches to increasing recovery—well work (workovers/redrills)
and reservoir characterization that leads to additional
development.
In the well work arena, factors are excessive
water production, formation damage and emulsion blocking.
Several regional projects have addressed controlling water
production. With formation damage it is critical to really
study the damage (and the solution).
Proving the point on additional reservoir
characterization, Ershaghi cited Tidelands' Wilmington
field experience and the Venoco South Ellwood projects.
There, detailed 3-D reservoir characterization and
visualization identified undrained compartments that new
wells are profitably draining. When taking a serious
relook at a reservoir, there are insights to be gained
from reservoir analog studies such as those C&C Reservoirs
(www.ccreservoirs.com) has performed. Discussing
their findings, C&C noted that fluid type (gas,
conventional oil, or heavy oil), permeability and drive
mechanism are primary factors affecting recovery.
Underbalanced drilling (UBD), often in conjunction with
horizontals, is another important tool. Blade Energy
Partners drove home the point that UBD means "always
maintaining underbalance." Damage from overbalanced
drilling is particularly problematic in horizontals. UBD
may cost the same or a little more, but there are real
advantages from a cost avoidance (lost circulation, rate
of penetration) and recovery standpoint. With UBD it's not
just higher initial production—long-term production trends
indicate there is usually a true increase in estimated
ultimate recovery.
Additional recovery need not be exotic. The LATA Group's
nitrate-based biocompetitive exclusion process (www.latagroup.com)
addresses a common operational problem, reservoir souring.
Beyond this, when applied downhole, there can be a
beneficial enhanced oil recovery effect from microbial
byproducts. Through videotape, Mike Dennis, LATA Group's
president, shared several California- and other U.S.-based
case studies. Tex Boratko with Schlumberger described two
of their tools that help get valuable behind pipe
information: (1) the Cased Hole Formation Resistivity tool
enables through pipe resistivity measurements and (2) the
Cased Hole Dynamics Tester drills small holes through pipe
into the reservoir, retrieves fluid samples, then
mechanically plugs the holes. Fluid and pressure data are
invaluable for evaluating recompletions or redrills.
Technology alone is not the complete answer. The West
Coast Region's 2005 Tech Transfer Award went to Oxy and
the State Lands Commission. Oxy applied high angle,
extended-reach drilling to redevelop a previously
abandoned (1990s) state lease in the Belmont Field.
Drilling from existing Oxy facilities in Long Beach's
Chaffee Island, there was minimum environmental impact.
Production rates from initial wells have been quite
attractive and more are planned. The State Lands
Commission demonstrated permitting flexibility that
allowed this redevelopment to occur.
|